Super Bowl LX Novelty Predictions

Super Bowl Sunday isn’t just about sides and totals. Some of the most fun action on the board comes from novelty props, and every year, bettors go crazy over things like the coin toss, the Gatorade bath, and trickier in-game markets like two-point conversions. Well, we're no different!

We’re rolling with three novelty prop picks for Super Bowl 60 between the New England Patriots and Seattle Seahawks. Let’s dive into our favorite angles and why history backs them up.

Super Bowl 60 Novelty Prop Bets

• PICK #1: Coin Toss Result – Tails (-110)
• PICK #2: Gatorade Bath Color – Blue (+200)
• PICK #3: Successful 2-Point Conversion – Yes (+300)

PICK #1: Coin Toss Result – Tails (-110)

For our first novelty pick, we’re backing tails on the opening coin toss. Yes, it’s technically a 50/50 proposition, but Super Bowl history has leaned slightly toward tails over the years.

Dating back to Super Bowl I, tails has come up more often than heads, with tails hitting just over half the time. More recently, tails has shown up in six of the last 10 Super Bowls. Plus, you’ll always hear bettors joke that “tails never fails.” Obviously, this is still a coin flip, but if you’re looking for a tiny historical edge in a fun market, tails is the side to choose.

PICK #2: Gatorade Bath Color – Blue (+200)

For our second pick, we’re going with blue Gatorade to be dumped on the winning head coach. Orange has historically been the most common Gatorade color in Super Bowl history, but blue has quietly become one of the most popular options in recent years. It’s shown up three times over the past decade, and teams often stick to flavors they like or colors that match their uniforms.  

That’s important here because both the Patriots and Seahawks have blue as a primary team color. Additionally, the Pats have dumped Blue Gatorade after winning two of their last three Super Bowls. Whether it’s superstition or just branding, there’s often some correlation between team colors and the Gatorade choice on the sideline. At +200 odds, blue offers a solid mix of probability and payout, making it one of the more interesting novelty props on the board.

PICK #3: Successful 2-Point Conversion – Yes (+300)

For our final novelty prop, we’re taking Yes on a successful 2-point conversion. We expect this game to come down to the wire with the spread sitting around 4.5 points. An interesting nugget is that the Patriots kicker, Andy Borregales, missed two extra points during the regular season. With the pressure of the big game, he could end up missing an extra point, causing the Patriots to have to go for two to try to tie the game late.

The league-wide success rate on two-point tries sits around 50%, so if a team attempts one, there’s a real chance it cashes. In a high-stakes Super Bowl where every point matters, it wouldn’t be surprising to see at least one successful conversion. On top of that, both the Patriots and Seahawks had a 100% success rate on 2-pt conversions this season. At a +300 price, this is a classic high-upside novelty prop that’s worth a sprinkle.