Which Legal Sportsbook should you Sign Up with in New York?

New York Legal Online Sports Betting kicked off in January 2022, and is already the largest online state by handle and every other metric. There are currently eight online Sportsbooks in the Empire State, and we've taken a look at all of them. We haven't included one book in the review, Bally Sportsbook, as they have not launched their full offering yet. A heads up that we also haven't recommended just one, as each have their own strengths and weaknesses. However, we have looked into the Sportsbooks and found which ones are the best in specific areas. This can help you choose the right one for your sports betting needs.

Which Sportsbook Offers the Best Sign-Up Bonus Offer?

In our New York Sportsbook comparison, we determined that PointsBet has the best sign-up offer. New players are rewarded handsomely with two risk-free bets of up to $2,000. The offer is for two bets, one worth $500 for fixed odds and one for $1,500 in the PointsBetting system, which has a higher risk but higher rewards. Lose either bet, and the site will match it 100% in site credit.

Other sportsbooks also offer risk-free bets, such as FanDuel ($1,000) and Caesars ($1,500), but with PointsBet offering more money in their sign-up offer, they are the top dog. See all of the Sportsbook offers available in New York via our summary page here.

Which Sportsbook Offers the Best Ongoing Promotions

Caesars takes the top spot for New York sportsbooks regarding ongoing promotions. The gambling industry giant not only has a solid welcome offer in the form of a risk-free bet up to $1,500, but also a great variety of ongoing promotions. Their promos include risk-free same game parlays, Bet for a Boost, parlay profit boosts, parlay insurance, a refer-a-friend bonus, and same game parlays. Caesars also has a solid lineup regarding seasonal promotions for bigger events such as the World Series and Super Bowl. If you look at our Odds Boost Aggregator where we collate all of the Sportsbook's Odds Boosts on one page, you will see that a huge proportion of the offers are from Caesars.

Which Sportsbook Offers the Best Odds

There is a tie between Caesars and PointsBet regarding which New York Sportsbook offers the best odds. They both strive to have competitive odds and successfully do so. We have seen that throughout the NFL Season that PointsBet have been posting their Spread with -107 odds, which is market leading (all others are running at 10% Vig at -110). More generally though, Caesars have been running a lower Vig across the board across all bet types. 

You need to know that the odds can vary between Sportsbooks depending on how much money the books take in for a game or match. This is why it’s advantageous to have accounts with multiple New York sportsbooks, so you can get the most bang for your buck by making a bet with the most favorable odds. We recommend you use our Odds Comparison tool to help you shop the best odds and lines.

Which Sportsbook the Best User Interface?

It’s a tie between DraftKings and FanDuel for the New York Sportsbook that offers the best user interface. These two Sportsbooks are two of the most popular in the American market, and the platforms for each are superb whether you are wagering online or through your mobile device. Each platform is very slick and simple to navigate, and glitches and downtime are rare. According to a 2021 study by Eilers & Krejcik Gaming, both the DraftKings and FanDuel apps ranked in the top five for application features, overall user experience, and aesthetics.

Who Offers the Best Customer Service?

Caesars is the New York Sportsbook that has the best customer service. They offer support via live chat, email, and online help, and you will see all three options when you click on the Support link at the top of the landing page. One of the reasons they are the best for support is that live chat is available 24/7. The Sportsbook is prompt and quick when it comes to responding to support emails.

In terms of online help, Caesars has many helpful articles where it is simple to find the answer to many questions. Some of the links available are Payments, Getting Started, House Rules, Promotions, and My Account. On the Support page, a Help link takes you to another page with more help articles. There is also a search box where you can input your question, and all of the articles that match will be shown