Skip to main content

Seton Hall vs. Wisconsin Prediction, Men's College Basketball Odds & Best Bets (11/19)

· by OddsCrowd Analysts

Fact checked at 1:21 PM ET, Nov 19, 2026Odds as of 12:44 PM ET, Nov 19, 2026

Seton Hall and Wisconsin have never played each other, and their first meeting is a Baha Mar Championship semifinal at 8:30 PM ET on a neutral floor in Nassau. The winner gets NC State or Murray State for the title. Wisconsin is 4-0 and a 5-point favorite, but every one of those wins came at home against a mid-major, and three were decided by single digits. Seton Hall is 3-1, with its only loss an 82-76 game at Alabama. The way we see it, the Pirates' defense turns this into a slow, close game, and a close game keeps Seton Hall's starters on the floor all night. So we're taking Seton Hall with the points and Elijah Fisher's combined points, rebounds and assists.

Seton Hall vs. Wisconsin Predictions

  1. Pick #1Seton Hall +5−107
  2. Pick #2Elijah Fisher 15+ Points + Rebounds + Assists−190
Odds as of 12:44 PM ET, Nov 19, 2026Compare odds

Pick #1Seton Hall +5−107

Three public projections average Wisconsin by 3.0, two points inside this number, and none of them has the Badgers winning by more than 4. At -107, Seton Hall implies 51.7%.

Seton Hall's defense is why. The Pirates have allowed 61.5 points a game and have at least seven steals in every game. At Alabama they held a team averaging 102.0 points to 82, and to 7 made threes on 21 attempts when the Tide had been averaging 16.3 makes on 42.3 tries. They also cut a 17-point deficit to three in the final minute, without Terry Copeland Jr., who was ill. And they play slowly, around 300th nationally in tempo in one public rating, so a favorite gets fewer possessions to build a margin.

Wisconsin hasn't faced anything like this. Its wins came against Denver (75-68), Delaware (73-64), Fairfield (89-42) and Coastal Carolina (89-81), and tonight is its first game away from home. Coach Greg Gard expects "a level of physicality and pressure we haven't seen." Braeden Carrington, who averages 14.0 points, made the trip after taking an elbow to the head against Coastal Carolina. Gard said his recovery has gone faster than expected, and Jack Janicki would start if he can't.

Owen Foxwell is the problem. He averages 19.3 points and 5.5 assists, he scored 33 against Coastal Carolina, and one Wisconsin preview picks the Badgers by 6. Seton Hall's offense is limited at 69.3 points a game, and the flu has been through the roster: Devin Williams was very sick and missed practice after the Alabama game, though he made the trip. Most of the spread bets are on Seton Hall as well.

Pick #2Elijah Fisher 15+ Points + Rebounds + Assists−190

Fisher is playing more this season, and the numbers have followed. Last season he averaged about 20 minutes for Seton Hall, with 6.6 points, 2.9 rebounds and 0.8 assists, nowhere near 15 combined. This season he has started all four games and played 32, 32, 33 and 20 minutes, most recent first, for combined totals of 19, 15, 22 and 12. He reached 15 in all three games where he played 30 minutes or more. The miss was 20 minutes in a 66-42 win over Saint Peter's, when the starters sat. Two seasons ago at Pacific, at 33.6 minutes a game, he averaged 15.7 points and 4.8 rebounds.

So this is a bet on minutes, and a close game is where Fisher gets them. Seton Hall's frontcourt is short as well, with backup center Abdulai Fanta Kabba staying home. Against Alabama, Fisher had 14 points and 5 rebounds in 32 minutes. Against LIU he had 12 points, 5 rebounds and 5 assists.

The price is steep. -190 implies 65.5%, and the margin has been thin: he got to exactly 15 against Charlotte. Copeland's return could cost him some rebounds, although Fisher put up 22 against LIU with Copeland in the lineup. Wisconsin starts 7-footer Nolan Winter, who had 14 rebounds against Denver, so nothing on the glass comes free. When he has played 30 minutes, he has gotten there every time.

21+ (18+ where permitted). Odds subject to change. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, call 1-800-GAMBLER.

More NCAAB News & Insight