Skip to main content

Rutgers vs. Notre Dame Prediction, Men's College Basketball Odds & Best Bets (11/18)

· by OddsCrowd Analysts

Fact checked at 7:49 AM ET, Nov 18, 2026Odds as of 7:09 AM ET, Nov 18, 2026

Rutgers and Notre Dame both lost in Las Vegas a day ago, and they meet on the same neutral floor at 2:00 PM ET in the Players Era consolation game. Florida beat Notre Dame 86-78. Houston beat Rutgers 85-73. Notre Dame is a 3.5-point favorite and the total is 149.5. The Irish (4-1) average 85.6 points and have made 46% of their threes. Their two close games, against Villanova and Florida, are where Braeden Shrewsberry logged his biggest minutes and Brady Koehler kept scoring: the pair combined for 31 points against Villanova and 37 against Florida. We expect another tight one, and that keeps both of them on the floor. Rutgers (3-1) beat New Haven, NJIT and Bryant at home, then trailed Houston 45-30 at halftime before winning the second half 43-40 behind Lino Mark's 22 points and Christian Gurdak's 20.

Rutgers vs. Notre Dame Predictions

  1. Pick #1Brady Koehler 15+ Points−140
  2. Pick #2Braeden Shrewsberry 20+ Points + Rebounds + Assists−130
Odds as of 7:09 AM ET, Nov 18, 2026Compare odds

Pick #1Brady Koehler 15+ Points−140

Koehler hasn't scored fewer than 14 points in a game this season. His five games go 17, 16, 14, 17 and 16, newest first, so he's at 15 or more in four of five. He's a sophomore who played about 16 minutes a game as a freshman last season, so the role is new, but it has held up against the two high-major teams Notre Dame has played: 16 against Villanova and 17 against Florida, 14 of those after halftime. He's also 13 of 22 from three.

His minutes should stay high, too. Backup center Tommy Ahneman is out six to eight weeks with an arm injury, and against Florida starting center Logan Duncomb fouled his way to 17 minutes. Koehler played a season-high 32. Notre Dame is still thin up front, and a close game keeps its best scoring forward out there.

The -140 price implies a 58.3% chance, and fouls are what could beat it. Koehler has picked up four in two of his five games, and a fifth sends him to the bench for good. Rutgers' opponents have also made just 25 of 96 threes (26%), though three of those four opponents were New Haven, NJIT and Bryant.

Pick #2Braeden Shrewsberry 20+ Points + Rebounds + Assists−130

Shrewsberry plays his biggest minutes when Notre Dame's games are tight. He played 36 minutes in the 74-72 win over Villanova and 33 against Florida, and he finished those games with 24 and 26 combined points, rebounds and assists. Against Florida he scored a season-best 20 with five threes after halftime, and he and Koehler put up 30 second-half points between them.

His totals this season run 26, 13, 20, 24 and 24, newest first, so he's reached 20 in four of five games. The 13 came in 27 minutes of a 99-59 rout of South Carolina State, the night Ethan Roberts made 10 threes. A 3.5-point spread doesn't look like that kind of game. At -130, the implied probability is 56.5%.

This one depends on his shooting. He has had between three and six rebounds and between one and five assists, so a cold shooting day sinks it. A Notre Dame runaway that sends the starters to the bench early would hurt as well.

21+ (18+ where permitted). Odds subject to change. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, call 1-800-GAMBLER.

More NCAAB News & Insight