Skip to main content

Blues vs. Penguins Prediction, NHL Odds & Best Bets (11/19)

· by OddsCrowd Analysts

Fact checked at 1:22 PM ET, Nov 19, 2026Odds as of 12:44 PM ET, Nov 19, 2026

St. Louis (10-9-2) plays in Pittsburgh (7-11-2) at 7:00 PM ET, two nights after beating Anaheim 8-6 for a season-high eight goals. That was the outlier. In the four games before it, the Blues scored five goals, plus a shootout winner at Utah. Pittsburgh hasn't played in five days, since a 4-1 home loss to Ottawa, and is still missing Bryan Rust, Elmer Soderblom and Ryan Graves.

The biggest edge in this game is in the St. Louis net. Joel Hofer starts with an 8-6-1 record and a .921 save percentage, against a Pittsburgh team that scores exactly 3.00 goals a game. The Blues score 2.95. This one should play a lot tighter than the 8-6 game, and we're fading two players whose output has lagged their roles: Sidney Crosby as a setup man against Hofer, and Jake Neighbours as a shooter on a top line that runs through Robert Thomas and Jimmy Snuggerud.

Blues vs. Penguins Predictions

  1. Pick #1Sidney Crosby Under 0.5 Assists−150
  2. Pick #2Jake Neighbours Under 1.5 Shots on Goal−135
Odds as of 12:44 PM ET, Nov 19, 2026Compare odds

Pick #1Sidney Crosby Under 0.5 Assists−150

Crosby has seven assists in 20 games, and they've come in just six of them. He has gone without one in 14 of 20, including four of his last five, and the one he did get in that stretch was a power-play helper at Anaheim. Thirteen points, six of them goals, is a long way off his usual pace.

It isn't a minutes problem. He centers Evgeni Malkin and Rickard Rakell, runs the first power-play unit (Malkin is on the second) and has logged roughly 17 to 23 minutes a night over his last 10 games. Tonight he gets the best goalie in the building. Hofer has started 15 of St. Louis's 21 games, and in his second-to-last start he stopped all 29 shots at Utah through regulation and overtime. Pittsburgh's power play converts 20% of its chances.

-150 works out to a 60.0% chance. The Blues know exactly who they're dealing with. "If you're going to stop Pittsburgh, you're going to stop him," St. Louis coach Jim Montgomery said. Crosby put seven shots on goal at San Jose two games ago, the Penguins are rested, and one good shift with Malkin and Rakell beats this bet.

Pick #2Jake Neighbours Under 1.5 Shots on Goal−135

Neighbours is back on the top line with Thomas and Snuggerud, where he moved for the Anaheim game, and he has a spot on the first power-play unit. That line runs through the other two. Snuggerud leads St. Louis with 10 goals on 46 shots, and Thomas leads the team with 13 assists. Neighbours had a turn on that line earlier this season as well and managed one shot against Boston and none at Detroit.

Over the full season he has 35 shots in 21 games, about 1.7 a night, and one or none in 13 of them, including seven of his last 10. At -135, the implied probability is 57.4%.

What gives us pause is the Anaheim game. In his first night back with Thomas he scored and fired five shots, and Pittsburgh's goaltending invites volume. Arturs Silovs starts with a 3.35 goals-against average and an .873 save percentage, and the Penguins allow 3.50 goals a game, tied for 25th in the league. If the Blues fall behind and chase, or pile on early, he'll get more looks. We'll side with the tighter game, and he has 11 fewer shots than Snuggerud in the same 21 games.

21+ (18+ where permitted). Odds subject to change. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, call 1-800-GAMBLER.

More NHL News & Insight