Skip to main content

Blue Jackets vs. Islanders Prediction, NHL Odds & Best Bets (11/17)

· by OddsCrowd Analysts

Fact checked at 6:39 AM ET, Nov 17, 2026Odds as of 5:38 AM ET, Nov 17, 2026

Columbus (7-11-0) opens a four-game road trip against the Islanders (9-6-4) at 7:00 PM ET in Elmont, and it brings one of the league's weakest offenses along. The Blue Jackets score 2.39 goals a game, 30th of 32 teams. They've lost four straight, they're 1-5-0 on the road, and they'll again be without head coach Rick Bowness, who has missed the last two games with a health issue and stayed in Columbus for medical testing. Center Sean Monahan is out too. New York comes home after taking five of six points in California, finishing with a 5-2 win in Los Angeles and a 6-2 win in Anaheim. The Islanders are -141 on the moneyline, the total is 5.5, and New York pays +176 on the puck line.

We expect New York to win a controlled game against a team that can't finish. Columbus should get its shots while it chases, and New York won't need a big shooting night from Bo Horvat.

Blue Jackets vs. Islanders Predictions

  1. Pick #1Islanders Moneyline−141
  2. Pick #2Bo Horvat Under 3.5 Shots on Goal−160
  3. Pick #3Charlie Coyle Over 1.5 Shots on Goal−155
Odds as of 5:38 AM ET, Nov 17, 2026Compare odds

Pick #1Islanders Moneyline−141

Columbus has scored two goals or fewer in four of its last five games: a 2-1 win over Dallas, then losses of 5-2 at Buffalo, 4-1 to Florida and 3-1 to Tampa Bay before a 4-3 home loss to Philadelphia. New York averages 3.11 goals a game, 16th in the league, and scored 11 in its last two.

The goaltending should tilt New York's way as well. Ilya Sorokin (.915 save percentage) is expected to start after Semyon Varlamov played in Anaheim, although neither team has confirmed a starter. Columbus is less settled. Jet Greaves (.875) started and lost each of the last two games, and at least one lineup site projects Cam Talbot (.909), who would make this a harder night. A price of -141 implies a 58.5% chance, and against a road team on a four-game skid with no head coach on the bench, we think New York clears it.

Bettors like the winner more than the margin. 93% of the moneyline money is on New York from 80% of the bets, while 85% of the puck-line money sits on Columbus +1.5 from 66% of the bets.

The Islanders are only 4-3-2 at home and have won 9 of their 19 games, and Columbus has beaten Colorado 7-2 and Dallas. If Varlamov starts instead of Sorokin, the case gets thinner. The moneyline includes overtime and the shootout.

Pick #2Bo Horvat Under 3.5 Shots on Goal−160

New York doesn't win on volume. The Islanders average 25.5 shots a game, sixth-fewest in the league, and those shots get spread around. Matthew Schaefer has 65 on the season to Horvat's 61, and Simon Holmström, Horvat's winger, has five goals and three assists over his last four games, including a hat trick in Anaheim.

Horvat centers the top line between Holmström and Kyle Palmieri and plays on the first power-play unit, so there's no question about his role. The question is the count. He has three or fewer shots in 13 of 19 games this season (68.4%), against a price that implies 61.5%. Lately he has scored without shooting much, with two points on three shots in Anaheim and a goal on two shots in Los Angeles.

His longer record is tighter. Last season he stayed at three or fewer in 41 of 68 games (60.3%), just under tonight's number, and he put four shots on Columbus in each of the teams' last two meetings. He also had seven at San Jose in a shootout loss and five against Los Angeles earlier this season. A night New York spends chasing is the risk. If the Islanders play from ahead, Columbus does the chasing, and a normal Horvat night stays under.

Pick #3Charlie Coyle Over 1.5 Shots on Goal−155

Coyle should get his looks. New York allows 29.1 shots a game, seventh-most in the league, and a Columbus team playing from behind will keep throwing pucks at Sorokin. In Columbus's last game, the first without Monahan, Coyle played almost 22 minutes, worked the first power-play unit and put five shots on net. He has two or more shots in 8 of his last 10 games and 11 of 18 this season, and the -155 price implies 60.8%.

His floor is the problem. Last season, on fewer minutes, he reached two shots in 37 of 79 games (46.8%). Even in his last ten he had none at Philadelphia and one against Dallas, and he played barely 15 minutes against Florida. If Columbus draws few power plays or never trails, he can stall at one.

21+ (18+ where permitted). Odds subject to change. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, call 1-800-GAMBLER.

More NHL News & Insight